Potbelly Menu & Prices: A Wreck, Toasted Sandwiches, Chicken Pot Pie Soup, Cookies & Shakes

Last updated: November 2, 2026

Potbelly began in 1977 as a sandwich counter inside a Chicago antique shop. Owner Peter Hastings started toasting sandwiches on the shop’s old potbelly stove for browsing customers in the Lincoln Park store, and the sandwiches quietly took over the business. Regular Bryant Keil bought the shop in 1996 and turned the neighborhood curiosity into a national chain — today there are more than 400 Potbelly shops, still headquartered in Chicago and, since 2025, owned by RaceTrac. The formula never changed: fresh-baked bread, hand-sliced meats and every sandwich run through a toaster oven until the cheese melts, in rooms still decorated with antiques and, often, live local music. The full story is in the Potbelly Sandwich Shop history; the menu below is the current board.

One thing to know before the prices: Potbelly does not publish one national price list online. Potbelly’s official website carries the menu, catering and the Perks program, but prices appear only once you pick a shop and start an order. So every price below was read on 2 November 2026 from one named reference restaurant — Potbelly at 1200 McKinney Street in Houston, Texas — on that shop’s own merchant-set listing. A cross-check shop in the chain’s hometown, at 57 East Chicago Avenue in Chicago, carried the identical roster at prices roughly 50 cents to a dollar higher across the board. Other markets move both ways: Minnetonka, Minnesota ran lower on the same items, Portland, Oregon higher. Prices marked with a + are starting prices — they step up with size and add-ons. Treat these as a labelled snapshot, never as national prices.

Potbelly Menu at a Glance

DetailWhat to know
Known forOven-toasted sandwiches — above all A Wreck® — plus Chicken Pot Pie Soup, fresh-baked cookies and hand-dipped shakes
Sandwich sizesSkinny (thinner bread, less filling), Originals (the regular size since 1977) and BIGS (30% bigger)
Typical sandwich price$8.39–$10.59 starting prices at our Houston reference shop; Chicago ran $9.09–$11.59 for the same builds
Best value formatPick-your-Pair: a Skinny sandwich with a cup of soup for $13.29 at the reference shop
Founded1977, Lincoln Park, Chicago, by Peter Hastings; expanded from 1996 by Bryant Keil
Locations400+ shops across the US, concentrated in the Midwest, Texas and the Mid-Atlantic
KidsKids’ Combos with a kid sandwich or mac & cheese, applesauce, a mini cookie and a drink
Good to knowThe signature Hot Peppers are sold by the jar ($8.79) — and shakes are hand-dipped, never machine-poured

Sandwich Sizes, Breads & Toppings

Every Potbelly sandwich comes in three sizes. Originals are the regular size, unchanged since 1977. BIGS go 30% bigger on meat and cheese. Skinnys use thinner-cut bread with less meat and cheese — roughly a lighter third, and the base of the Pick-your-Pair combos below. You also pick your bread (the standard roll or multigrain), and every sandwich is toasted whether you ask or not — that oven pass is the whole Potbelly difference.

After toasting, sandwiches are finished to order: lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, mayo, deli mustard, oil and Italian seasoning are the standard line, and the chain’s signature Hot Peppers — a spicy giardiniera-style relish regulars ask for by name — are the add-on that defines the house style. They are popular enough that Potbelly sells them by the jar ($8.79 at the reference shop) for home sandwiches.

Toasted Sandwiches — With Prices

The board runs to nineteen sandwiches at the reference shop, all hand-sliced and toasted. Prices below are Houston starting prices; the Chicago cross-check shop priced the same roster from $8.89 (Grilled Cheese) up to $11.59 (Prime Rib Steak).

SandwichWhat is on itPrice
A Wreck®The signature: turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef and salami with Swiss$8.89+
ItalianSalami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella and provolone$8.89+
Turkey BreastHand-sliced turkey breast with Swiss — the shop’s most-ordered sandwich$8.39+
Chicken ClubAll-natural grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon and cheddar$9.39+
Avo TurkeyHand-sliced turkey breast, Swiss, fresh-sliced avocado and cucumbers$9.39+
Prime Rib SteakTender sliced prime rib steak, Swiss, housemade caramelized onions and garlic aioli$10.59+
Pastrami ReubenHand-sliced pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing and pickles$10.09+
PastramiHand-sliced pastrami and Swiss with deli mustard and pickles$10.09+
CubanoSlow-cooked pulled pork, hickory smoked ham, Swiss, deli mustard and pickles$8.89+
Sweet Heat Pork BBQSlow-cooked pulled pork, cheddar, pickles and sweet-heat BBQ sauce made with the signature hot peppers$9.19+
Mama’s MeatballHomestyle beef and pork meatballs in marinara with provolone and Italian seasoning$8.89+
Pizza MeltPepperoni, capicola, crumbled meatball, marinara, provolone, Italian seasoning and mushrooms (where available)$8.89+
BLTAApplewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and fresh-sliced avocado$8.89+
MediterraneanAll-natural grilled chicken, feta, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, cucumbers and hot pepper hummus$9.39+
Grilled ChickenAll-natural grilled chicken with cheddar$8.39+
Smoked HamHickory smoked ham with Swiss$8.39+
Tuna Salad100% albacore tuna salad with Swiss$8.39+
Chicken SaladThe shop’s own chicken salad with provolone$8.39+
Veggie MeltFresh-sliced avocado, Swiss, cheddar, provolone and mushrooms (where available)$8.39+
Grilled CheeseThe simple toasted build — the cheapest sandwich on the board$7.99+

If you order one sandwich, make it A Wreck — four meats and Swiss through the oven is the build the chain was named on. The Italian is its cold-cut cousin; the Prime Rib Steak is the premium order, and the Pastrami pair (Reuben and the plain Pastrami & Swiss) are the newest deli-style additions to the board.

Wraps

Potbelly’s newest format wraps the sandwich fillings warm in a tortilla instead of the roll. Both wraps were $13.29+ at the reference shop ($14.29+ in Chicago): the Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap. They sit at a premium over the sandwiches — you are paying for the format — but they travel better and eat lighter than a BIGS.

Salads

Four salads, each built on field greens and each $9.09+ at the reference shop ($9.59+ in Chicago). Dressing choices include buttermilk ranch, balsamic vinaigrette, fat-free vinaigrette and the house Potbelly vinaigrette; half salads exist as part of the Pick-your-Pair combos below.

SaladWhat is in itPrice
Farmhouse SaladGrilled chicken, crispy bacon, crumbled blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes with buttermilk ranch$9.09+
Apple Walnut SaladGrilled chicken, crumbled blue cheese, grapes, apples, dried cranberries and candied walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette$9.09+
Powerhouse SaladGrilled chicken, fresh-sliced avocado, hummus, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes with fat-free vinaigrette$9.09+
Chicken Salad SaladThe shop’s chicken salad with provolone, dried cranberries, cucumbers and tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette$9.09+

Mac & Soups — With Prices

Potbelly’s soups are the strongest supporting act in fast-casual sandwiches, and one of them is famous. The Chicken Pot Pie Soup — tender, slow-roasted chicken breast and vegetables in a creamy base with a flaky crumb topping — tastes exactly like the inside of a pot pie, and it has been the cult order for years. All seven entries on the reference shop’s Mac & Soups board start at the same price, $6.29, with Chili Mac a dime less; in Chicago the same section ran $6.79 across the board. Prices are for the starting size and step up from cup to bowl.

A steaming bowl of creamy chicken pot pie soup with chunks of chicken, peas, carrots and pieces of flaky crust, with plain crackers on a wooden table beside it
Soup or macWhat it isPrice
Chicken Pot Pie SoupSlow-roasted chicken and vegetables with a flaky crumb topping$6.29+
Loaded Baked PotatoHearty potato soup with bacon, cheddar cheese and green onion$6.29+
Broccoli CheddarCreamy cheese soup with tender broccoli and carrots$6.29+
ChiliHearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers and onions$6.29+
Garden VegetableThe vegan-leaning vegetable soup$6.29+
Mac & CheeseCreamy three-cheese mac — and a menu headline in its own right$6.29+
Chili MacThe beef chili ladled over the three-cheese mac$6.19+

Pick-your-Pair Combos

The pairing board is where regulars actually eat. At the reference shop: a Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup is $13.29, a Half Salad + Cup of Soup is $13.59, and a Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad is $15.19. The soup cup can be a soup, the chili or the mac & cheese, which makes the Skinny-plus-pot-pie-soup combination the best-value full lunch in the shop — it was the single most-ordered item at both stores we read in full.

Chips & Sides

Potbelly stocks Zapp’s potato chips — the Louisiana kettle chips in Regular, VooDoo, Mesquite Bar-B-Que, Hotter ‘N Hot Jalapeño, Salt & Vinegar and a Hot Pepper flavor made for the chain — plus Baked Lay’s and Utz Cheese Curls, all $2.79 at the reference shop ($3.09 in Chicago). The Potbelly Whole Pickle is $1.89, and the bundle shortcuts are Chips + Drink or Chips + Shake at $5.09 each. A jar of the signature Hot Peppers to take home is $8.79.

Cookies & Shakes — With Prices

Dessert is a small department run with unusual care. Cookies are baked fresh in each shop through the day — time it right and yours is still warm — and the shakes are hand-dipped and hand-mixed, never dispensed from a machine, each finished with the chain’s signature shortbread cookie riding on the straw.

A thick sugar-dusted sugar cookie beside a hand-scooped vanilla ice cream sandwich made with two cookies, on a small speckled plate
SweetWhat it isPrice
Sugar CookieThe signature bake — thick, soft, fresh from the shop’s oven$3.09
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip CookieThe longtime Potbelly favorite, also sold as a bag of a dozen minis ($6.29)$3.09
Chocolate Brownie CookieA brownie in cookie form$3.09
Dream BarThe chewy oat, chocolate and caramel-coconut bar — a cult item with its own following$3.39
6-Pack Cookie BoxSix full-size cookies for the table or the office$14.39+
Vanilla / Chocolate / Strawberry ShakeHand-dipped classics$6.69+
OREO® Cookie ShakeThe most-ordered of the specialty shakes$7.09+
Cold Brew / Banana Pudding / English Toffee ShakeThe rotating specialty line$7.09+

One more build worth knowing: many shops will make you an Ice Cream Sandwich — a scoop of ice cream between any two cookies — even though it does not appear on the reference shop’s current listing, so we print no price for it here; ask at the counter. Seasonal cookies rotate through the case as well (a Lemon Cheesecake Cookie was the current special at another shop we checked).

Drinks

The reference shop’s drinks list is bottled: Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke and Coke Zero at $4.29, IBC Root Beer and Cream Soda at $4.29, Arizona Tea at $4.29, Gold Peak teas and San Pellegrino at $4.39, Smartwater at $4.79 and bottled water from $3.19. In-shop, fountain drinks are the cheaper pour — the listings we read price the bottles, so treat the figures above as delivery-menu numbers and expect the counter price of a fountain cup to sit lower.

Kids’ Combos

The kids’ format, Kids’ Combos, pairs a kid-sized sandwich — the Turkey & Cheddar is the standard build — or a kid-sized Mac & Cheese with Mott’s applesauce, a mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookie and a choice of milk, chocolate milk or bottled water. Neither of the full listings we read prices the kids’ section, so we describe it without a figure rather than borrow one from a third-party menu: check the board or the app at your shop, where the combo is a single set price.

Breakfast — at Select Shops Only

Potbelly is a lunch-first chain, but a minority of shops — busy downtown and commuter locations among them — open early with a short breakfast board of toasted egg sandwiches: Bacon, Egg & Cheddar, Sausage, Egg & Cheddar, Egg & Cheddar, and Ham, Mushroom, Egg & Swiss, served until mid-morning (around 10:30–11:00 AM). Neither reference listing carries breakfast, so no prices are printed here; if your shop opens before 9 AM, it is the likeliest candidate, and the locator listing will say so.

Catering & Potbelly Perks

Catering is a real department, not an afterthought: the chain delivers and sets up catering orders, built around sandwich trays, boxed lunches and the same soups, salads and cookie trays as the shop board. Catering prices are quoted per order on the chain’s site, so none are printed here.

Potbelly Perks is the loyalty program, and it is unusually straightforward. Members earn coins — 10 for every $1 spent at the base Rookie level, rising to 11 per dollar at Pro and 12 at Boss — and redeem them for free menu items, with redemptions starting at just 200 coins. Levels also scale the free birthday perk (a cookie or Dream Bar at the base level, up to a shake or an entrée at the top), and members get 2x-coins days, app-only offers and access to the app’s Underground Menu of off-board builds. New members currently get a free Original sandwich after their first order of $5 or more.

What to Order First at Potbelly

If it is your first visit, order A Wreck — in Originals, with the hot peppers — because four meats through the toaster is the sandwich this chain exists to make. For the full classic lunch, the Pick-your-Pair of a Skinny sandwich with a cup of Chicken Pot Pie Soup is the most-ordered combination in the shop for a reason. For the lightest serious lunch, the Powerhouse Salad or a Skinny Mediterranean. For the table, a 6-Pack Cookie Box, or a single warm Sugar Cookie if the tray has just come out of the oven. To finish, a hand-dipped shake — OREO Cookie if you want the popular one, Banana Pudding if you want the interesting one — with the little cookie on the straw.

Vegetarian, Vegan & Gluten-Sensitive Notes

  • Vegetarian: A real bench: the Veggie Melt, Mediterranean (hold nothing — it is built on hummus and feta), Grilled Cheese, Garden Vegetable soup, the Mac & Cheese and any salad without chicken.
  • Vegan: Options are thinner: the Garden Vegetable soup, salads with the fat-free vinaigrette and no cheese or egg, and a custom vegetable build on the sandwich line — ask for no cheese and no mayo.
  • Gluten-sensitive: There is no published gluten-free bread or menu. The practical routes are the salads and soups and a sandwich build served over greens rather than in the roll. The chain publishes full nutrition and allergen information on its website — check it before ordering if you have celiac disease or a serious allergy, and flag it at the counter.

Practical Information

Finding a shop. There are 400+ Potbelly locations, heaviest in Chicago and the Midwest, with large clusters in Texas, Washington DC and the Northeast. The locator on the chain’s site carries addresses and hours; a growing number of suburban shops have drive-thrus.

Hours. No national timetable, and the spread is wide: flagship downtown Chicago shops can run 7:00 AM to 10:00 PM on weekdays, office-district shops may keep office hours only, and the typical suburban pattern is roughly 10:00 or 11:00 AM to 8:00 or 9:00 PM. Check your shop before an early or late run.

Ordering. Counter service in-shop; order ahead in the app or on the website for pickup, and use Perks when you do — coins only accrue when the order is attached to your account. Delivery runs through the chain and the usual apps at listing prices like the ones quoted here.

The setting. Antique-shop décor, mismatched furniture and, at many shops, a local musician playing at lunch — a holdover from the original store that the chain has kept deliberately.

FAQs

How much is a sandwich at Potbelly?

At our Houston reference shop, sandwiches start from $7.99 (Grilled Cheese) and $8.39–$8.89 for the core builds like the Turkey Breast, A Wreck and Italian, up to $10.59 for the Prime Rib Steak — starting prices that rise with size (Originals, BIGS) and add-ons. The Chicago cross-check shop ran about 50 cents to a dollar higher on the same sandwiches, so expect your shop to land near one of those two tiers.

What is in A Wreck at Potbelly?

Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef and salami with Swiss cheese, toasted and finished with your choice of toppings. It is the chain’s signature sandwich — the name is the joke: four meats in one sandwich is a wreck, in the best way. Order it with the house hot peppers.

What are Potbelly’s sandwich sizes?

Three: Skinny (thinner-cut bread, less meat and cheese), Originals (the regular size since 1977) and BIGS (30% more meat and cheese than an Original). Every sandwich is toasted regardless of size.

Does Potbelly still serve breakfast?

At select shops only. A short board of toasted breakfast sandwiches — bacon, sausage or ham with egg and cheese — runs at early-opening locations until around 10:30–11:00 AM. Most shops open later and start at lunch; the locator entry for your shop will show whether it serves breakfast.

What is the Chicken Pot Pie Soup?

A creamy soup of slow-roasted chicken breast and vegetables finished with a flaky crumb topping — deliberately built to taste like the inside of a chicken pot pie. It is the chain’s most famous soup, and the standard partner in the Pick-your-Pair combos. At the reference shop it starts at $6.29.

Is Potbelly’s cookie free with a shake?

The little shortbread cookie on the straw is part of the shake ritual — hand-dipped shakes are served with it. Cookies otherwise start at $3.09 at the reference shop, and Perks members get one free on their birthday at the base level.

Before You Go

  • Prices are per-shop. The figures above are one named Houston shop’s, checked 2 November 2026, with a Chicago shop running 50 cents to a dollar higher the same week — your shop’s board or app listing is the final word.
  • First visit: A Wreck, Originals, hot peppers. Then the Chicken Pot Pie Soup on the next one.
  • The Pick-your-Pair is the value play. A Skinny sandwich plus a cup of soup ($13.29 at the reference shop) beats most full-size sandwich-and-chips combinations on price and appetite.
  • Join Perks before you order. Coins accrue on every dollar, redemptions start at 200 coins, and the current welcome offer is a free Original sandwich after a first order of $5 or more.
  • Cookies are baked through the day. An early-afternoon visit gives you the best odds of a warm one — and of a Dream Bar still being in the case.

Enjoying the menu guides?

Follow MenuExplore for daily restaurant menus & prices — know the menu before you go.

Keep Exploring

Related Guides

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top